Sunday, November 16, 2025

New Novel by Peter Rodgers

6

I announce the publication of my fourth and final historical novel in the Scribes series, entitled "The Star of the East." It is set mostly in Ephesus, and  features the developing text of both the Greek New Testament and the Greek Old Testament (LXX) and the versions, Aquila, Symmachus and especially Theodotion. Notes at the end of the novel offer the reader the opportunity to learn more about the text and the late second century church and empire.

from the back cover:

The Star of the East: Nathan was a Jewish Christian scribe in the church of Rome. In 189 AD he was asked by his bishop to travel to Ephesus (with his colleague Justin) to represent the Roman church in its growing controversy with the eastern churches over the date for the celebration of Easter. Nathan is also charged with the task of reviewing the new translation of the Old Testament in Greek being prepared by Theodotion of Ephesus with the assistance of his granddaughter, Miriam. Follow Nathan as he discovers new challenges to the church’s unity, new approaches to the text and language of scripture, growing tensions between the church and the synagogue, and a friendship that would forever change his life. (Amazon, KDP, 2025)

Peter Rodgers

Saturday, November 15, 2025

New issue: TC Journal 30 (2025) at a New Home

2

Big News about TC: A Journal of Biblical Textual Criticism 

 

The TC journal has now begun migrating to a new homepage alongside Journal of Biblical Literature and Review of Biblical Literature at the Scholarly Publishing Collective and in terms of layout it has gone through an extreme make-over taking it from the 1990's into the 2020's in terms of appearance and accessibility.

 

 

The current volume 30 has just been published on the new homepage and all previous issues will migrate in the coming weeks. The journal was started by Jimmy Adair in 1996 and is one of the first open access academic electronic journals in the world. Personally I started working on this journal from the SBL meeting in 2009 and soon became senior editor. This also happens to be the journal in which I published my own first academic article back in 2002.

The 2025 volume contains five articles and four notes, and there will also be a number of reviews and a review article soon to be added. As ever, all content is open access.

ARTICLES

The Greek Subscriptions to Hebrews and the Position of the Letter in the Corpus Paulinum

Christian Schøler Holmgaard


Altered, Not Antique: The Latinized Greek Text of 1 Corinthians in GA 629

Andrew J. Patton

 

The Crux of Psalm 22:17: At the Crossroads of Textual and Literary Criticism

Seth D. Postell; Joseph L. Justiss

 

Otto Thenius and Zacharias Frankel on the Text of the Books of Samuel

Theo A.W. van der Louw

 

Revisiting GA 205 and 2886 in the Gospel of Mark: History, Reception, and Text

Matthew Whidden

 

Notes

A Note on the “Sons of God” in Latin Quotations of Deut 32:8d

Chrissy M. Hansen

 

Reuniting Codex Angus (GA L2378) with Its Lost Bifolium

Hefin J. Jones

 

Missing the Forest for the Trees: A Response to Richard Fellows

Elizabeth Schrader Polczer

 

The Presence of Martha in the Archetype of the Bethany Narrative in John: A Counter-Response to Elizabeth Schrader Polczer

Richard G. Fellows



Friday, November 14, 2025

Note on Job 30:28 in the Complutensian Polyglot

2

Today, I'm finalizing my ETS/SBL paper reviewing Biblia Hebraica Quinta Job (2024) and its use and citation of the Greek versions. For the most part, the editor, Robert Althann, conservatively follows Ziegler's Göttingen Iob (noting the few places where prior scholarship already corrected Ziegler). But in one place that I found, he decided to go his own way and suggested that Ziegler's reconstructed text is actually the variant, and the text in the apparatus should be considered the Old Greek.

The text in just about every Greek manuscript and daughter version reads στένων πεπόρευμαι ἄνευ φιμοῦ, ἕστηκα δὲ ἐν ἐκκλησίᾳ κεκραγώς “groaning without restraint I walked about, and I stood in the assembly crying out.” The Hebrew reads “I go about darkened, but not by the sun (בְּלֹא חַמָּה); I stand in the assembly and cry for help.” Rashi and the Targum confirm the reading of MT. On the other hand, Vulgate, Peshitta, and Symmachus (ἀθυμῶν) read חַמָּה “the sun” as חֵמָה “without heat, anger.”

In short, Althann proposes that the original translation had ἄνευ θυμοῦ “without anger” but was corrupted to ἄνευ φιμοῦ. The only evidence for this reading is the insignificant catena manuscript (Ra 523), Iulian's commentary, and the Complutensian Polyglot (!). As I was reviewing the Polyglot, I couldn't help but notice that the Vulgate's (sine furore) “without anger” was also the text of the newly prepared interlinear Latin translation of the Greek, which must have been corrected to read ἄνευ θυμοῦ “without anger.” Given the evidence, it seems the editor of the Comp Pol corrected the Greek of the Seventy towards the Latin of the Vulgate.

It turns out, Ziegler had already concluded similarly about the Comp. Pol. here and in Job 38:30 in his Einleitung (p. 57), “In his revision according to M, the editor consulted the Vulgate in several places.” Although the Greek manuscripts for parts of the Comp. Pol. are unknown, in the case of Job at least, we know that Cardinal Ximenes used the manuscript Rahlfs 248 loaned to him by the Vatican which had ἄνευ φιμοῦ.


Thus, the editors of the Comp. Pol. did not simply print the text of their manuscript. They made corrections towards the Hebrew, probably via the Latin Vulgate as well as the many marginal readings of the Three Jewish revisers in Rahlfs 248. Althann's suggestion, based on Schleusner's own proposal, is probably to be rejected in light of this evidence. But I'm always happy to entertain and investigate new proposals like these, especially ones based on a plausible and known Hebrew source as BHQ attempted to do in this case.

UPDATE
BHQ followed Critique textuelle de l'Ancien Testament (vol. 5, p. 289) for this suggested correction to Ziegler's Iob. But CTAT does not engage Ziegler's Einleitung on the Complutensian Polyglot either.

Tuesday, November 11, 2025

The Blog Dinner Is On

2

Good news! After no small difficulty in finding a place to host us for the annual blog dinner, we think we have found a place. We are still working out details on the price, so stay tuned for ticket sales, which we hope to come out under $30. 

In the meantime, mark your calendars for Sunday, November 23, 2025 at Tremont Temple Baptist Church at 7:15pm. That should give us time to get to the church from the last TC session that evening. 

The address is 88 Tremont St, Boston, MA 02108. The church is about 1.5 miles from the Hynes Convention Center. That’s a 30 minute walk for us non-Olympian walkers. I’m sorry for that but it’s the best we could do. (Some of us from warmer climates may need to Uber to survive.)

We do hope many of you can make it as this is our 20th anniversary as a blog and the dinner is always the highlight of SBL for many of us. 


A special thanks to Christian Askeland and Peter Montoro for working on this!

Friday, November 07, 2025

Peter Martyr Vermigli on 1 John 5:7

1

I was just doing some reading in Peter Martyr Vermigli’s Commonplaces tonight and came across his treatment of 1 John 5:7–8. Vermigli (1499–1562) was a major Italian Reformer who seems to be gaining renewed appreciation today. 

In his section defending the divinity of the Holy Spirit, he brings up 1 John 5:7. What caught my attention is that he does not think he needs the Comma to prove the Trinity since he finds everything he needs theologically in the part of the text that is not in question. What’s interesting about this is that this same trinitarian interpretation of the three (earthly) witnesses is the most likely cause the the clause about the three heavenly witnesses. In other words, because Vermigli follows the early interpretation of 1 John 5:7–8, he does not need to follow the later text of it to prove his point. Had later theologians followed his lead, the debate about these verses might have been far less extended and acrimonious.

Here’s his discussion. The full source is here.

Monday, November 03, 2025

The Oxford Handbook of the Textual Criticism of the Bible, eds. Crawford & Wasserman

9

Any day now, Oxford University Press will publish The Oxford Handbook of the Textual Criticism of the Bible edited by Sidnie White Crawford and myself. I think we began working on this handbook in 2019, and there were many hurdles along the way, but soon I will hold the volume in my hand. Hopefully, the OUP will bring some copies to the SBL in Boston, but you can never be sure. In the meantime you can get 30% off with the promotion code AUFLY30 (enter code at checkout) at https://global.oup.com/academic/product/the-oxford-handbook-of-textual-criticism-of-the-bible-9780197581315.

Below the flyer, I have pasted the table of contents (minus page numbers).

It is possible to read a bit on google books (e.g., the whole introduction which summarizes the chapters). 

https://fdslive.oup.com/www.oup.com/academic/images/authors/promotion/9780197581315-discount.png  

Introduction

PART I OVERARCHING ISSUES

 

1. The Formation of the Jewish Canon

James C. VanderKam

 

2. The Formation of the Christian Canon

John D. Meade

 

3. Philosophies of Textual Criticism for the Hebrew Bible

Ronald Hendel

 

4. Beyond “Textual” and “Literary” Criticism: A New Paradigm for the Study of Textual History

Molly M. Zahn

 

5. Philosophies of Textual Criticism for the New Testament

Michael W. Holmes

 

6. Book History, New/ Material Philology, and Paratextual Criticism

David Davage and Liv Ingeborg Lied

 

PART II THE HEBREW BIBLE AND THE DEUTEROCANON

 

7. The History of Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible from Antiquity to the Twentieth Century

Eugene Ulrich and Sidnie White Crawford

 

8. The Earliest Texts of the Hebrew Bible

Emanuel Tov

 

9. The Masoretic Text and Its Value for Textual Criticism of the

Hebrew Bible

Armin Lange

 

10. The Significance of the Septuagint in the Textual Study of the Hebrew Bible

Anneli Aejmelaeus

 

11. The Samaritan Pentateuch and Its Value for Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible

Hila Dayfani

 

12. The Syriac Peshitta and Its Value for Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible

Bradley J. Marsh Jr.

 

13. The Latin Versions and Their Value for Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible

Andrés Piquer Otero and Pablo A. Torijano

 

14. The Targumim and Their Value for Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible

Leeor Gottlieb

 

15. Editing the Hebrew Bible: Biblia Hebraica Quinta

Innocent Himbaza

 

16. Editing the Hebrew Bible: The Hebrew University Bible Project

Michael Segal

 

17. Editing the Hebrew Bible: The Hebrew Bible: A Critical Edition

Ronald Hendel

 

18. Teaching Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible

John Screnock

 

19. The Theory and Practice of Textual Criticism of the Septuagint

Tuukka Kauhanen

 

20. The Practice of Hebrew Bible Textual Criticism in the

Twenty- First Century

Drew Longacre

 

21. Issues in the Textual Criticism of the Deuterocanon

Benjamin G. Wright III

 

PART III THE NEW TESTAMENT

 

22. The Practice of New Testament Textual Criticism in the Twenty- First Century

H. A. G. Houghton

 

23. The History of New Testament Textual Criticism

Jan Krans and An- Ting Yi

 

24. The Dating of Early Christian Manuscripts: Paleography and Material Culture

Pasquale Orsini

 

25. Text- Types and the Coherence- Based Genealogical Method

Peter J. Gurry

 

26. The Greek New Testament Manuscripts and Other Witnesses

Elijah Hixson

 

27. The Syriac and Christian Palestinian Aramaic Versions of the New Testament

Andreas Juckel

 

28. The Latin Versions of the New Testament

Georg Gäbel

 

29. The Coptic Versions of the New Testament

Christian Askeland

 

30. The Ethiopic Version of the New Testament

Curt Niccum

 

31. The Gothic Version of the New Testament

Carla Falluomini

 

32. Patristic Evidence in New Testament Textual Criticism

Holger Strutwolf

 

33. Criteria for the Assessment of Readings in New Testament Textual Criticism

Tommy Wasserman

 

34. The New Testament Text, Paratexts, and Reception History

Jennifer Wright Knust

 

35. New Testament Textual Criticism and Exegesis

Elizabeth E. Shively

 

36. New Testament Textual Criticism and Digital Humanities

Claire Clivaz

 

37. Critical Editions of the Greek New Testament from the Twentieth to Twenty- First Century

Annette Hüffmeier and Gregory S. Paulson

 

38. New Testament Textual Criticism in Teaching and Practice

Amy S. Anderson