Monday, January 08, 2007

Gospels in the 'Western' order

I have an enquiry from a scholar wishing to find out whether there is a list of all Greek manuscripts with the Gospels in the 'Western' order. Does anyone know of such a list?

3 Comments:

Peter M. Head said...

P45, D & W for a start. Other witnesses in Latin and Gothic. Not sure about any minuscules.

Mike Holmes said...

D. C. Parker, in his monograph on Codex Bezae (Codex Bezae: an early Christian manuscript and its text, CUP, 1992), pp. 116-118, has a detailed discussion of the matter, including evidence from Greek MSS (D, X, and a few minuscules), versions, and patristic testimony.
Surprisingly he does not mention p45.

Peter M. Head said...

Thanks Mike,

That is really helpful.

The lack of P45 is interesting. I suppose the fact of the matter is that the order of the gospels in P45 is not 100% secure.

Kenyon described P45 as originally being found/purchased in two bundles: Mark & Acts; Luke & John (‘in a much better state of preservation’). This suggests that Mark came last, and suggested the possibility that P45 originally had the "Western" order: Matt, John, Luke, Mark.
The subsequent analysis by Skeat (1993, one year after Parker's 1992) confirmed this and put the theory of the original "Western" order for P45 on a more secure footing: T.C. Skeat, "A Codicological Analysis of the Chester Beatty Papyrus Codex of the Gospels and Acts (P45)," Hermathena 155(1993), 27-43.